5368 Menzie Street, Niagara Falls, ON L2E 2V8
$1,790,000
$1,790,000

5368 Menzie Street

210 - Downtown, Niagara Falls, Niagara $1,790,000

Make an offer

6 Beds
5 Baths
3500-5000 sqft
Parking for 10
South Facing
Pool!
Zoning: R2, TRM
MLS®#:
X12579776
Property Type:
Multiplex
Property Style:
3-Storey
Area:
Niagara
Community:
210 - Downtown
Taxes:
$6,705 / 2025
Added:
November 26 2025
Lot Frontage:
96.22
Lot Depth:
219.77
Status:
Active
Outside:
Vinyl Siding
Year Built:
100+
Basement:
Unfinished,Full
Brokerage:
RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE
Lot :

219

96

BIG LOT

Intersection:
BRIDGE ST. & STANLEY AVE
Rooms:
Bedrooms:
6
Bathrooms:
5
Fireplace:
Utilities
Water:
Municipal
Cooling:
Central Air
Heating Type:
Forced Air
Heating Fuel:

Listing Details

Own a Rare Piece of Niagara's History - Endless Possibilities Await!Step into a truly one-of-a-kind estate where timeless elegance meets modern convenience. Legal 5-plex, this extraordinary property is currently configured as a spacious single-family home, and can be effortlessly returned back to a 5-plex income producer. It also presents an amazing bed & breakfast opportunity, especially with the impressive Viking pool. A rare luxury that sets this property apart. Boasting over 4,000 sq. ft. of living space, the home features remarkable architectural character, including 12' ceilings, original hardwood floors, solid 8' doors, intricate cove moulding, detailed plaster trim, a grand staircase, and a stunning solid marble fireplace mantel. Located just minutes from Niagara Falls' premier entertainment district, this property also offers dual street access, a rare advantage in Niagara plus ample parking. Additional highlights include: Empty apartments, allowing the new owner to set market rents. Development opportunities at the rear of the property. You can build 3 homes or possibly 5 towns. Ideal for a home-based business: perfect for a salon, daycare, accounting office, law office, or other professional use. If geared toward students, the layout offers numerous rooms, maximizing income potential. Revenue potential of up to $10,000 per month, depending on use and configuration. Over the past 26 years, nearly every major system has been updated, including: High-efficiency furnace & AC, newer windows and exterior doors, a 200-amp electrical panel, rebuilt back porch, updated fencing, and more (see the full upgrade sheet for details). Whether you're seeking a distinctive residence, a high-yield investment property, or a boutique hospitality venture, this rare gem delivers unmatched versatility, historic charm, and modern reliability. Envision the possibilities!

3 Fridges, 2 Gas Stoves, Washer, Dryer

Insights

  1. High Income Potential: This property can be configured as a legal 5-plex, offering significant rental income opportunities, with potential revenue of up to $10,000 per month depending on the configuration and use.
  2. Historic Charm with Modern Upgrades: The estate boasts remarkable architectural features and has undergone extensive updates over the past 26 years, ensuring both character and reliability for modern living.
  3. Prime Location with Development Potential: Located minutes from Niagara Falls' entertainment district, the property offers dual street access and the possibility to build additional homes or townhouses, enhancing its investment appeal.

Sale/Lease History of 5368 Menzie Street

View all past sales, leases, and listings of the property at 5368 Menzie Street.

Neighborhood Overview

Complete neighborhood profile for 5368 Menzie Street

210 - Downtown home prices

Average sold price for Detached, Semi-Detached, Condo, Townhomes in 210 - Downtown

Insights for 5368 Menzie Street

View the highest and lowest priced active homes, recent sales on the same street and postal code as 5368 Menzie Street, and upcoming open houses this weekend.

* Data is provided courtesy of TRREB (Toronto Regional Real-estate Board)